Wenin is one of the founding fathers of the NRLSCTalk website who's Tuesday Teams Analysis has been a feature post on the site for close to a decade. He also loves a good steak bet!
hey gents having the worst year ever and i need advice on how i should fix my team. been a fall from grace compared to least year didnt even crack 900 this week. i do plan to bring in may and then upgrade katoa to either cotter or talakai
starling / randall
Haas / AFB / King / King
Fifita Ola Katoa / tuilagi macdonald piakura
cleary / schiender
munster / ilias
bsmith tago amone penisini / russell vailea burbo
hynes / teddy
Mate even with may it might just give u 3 ctrs. go b smith + amone to manly young gun plus may first. Then maybe a boost for katoa if on bench again but with jazz out Curran maybe back to 13 he might start
Don’t panic brother. A week to forget for anyone who didn’t Captain Papy. You have a really good team that may very well score 1300 next week. Cleary, Hynes and Munster won’t score 100 points combined very often.
I think you need to bring in Cook or Grant for Starling
Trade Cleary out for the cash and bring him back once he proves he can reach 2021 scores again and he bottoms out in price
Get a dual 2RF/CTW like Aitkins or Fermour
Bring in Pappy
Cleary out Hynes to HB Pappy in
Amone out for May or Koula piakura or underperforming CTW out for Fermor/Aitken or starling out for Grant
My 2cents worth,
looks like you don’t have many players generating cash
thanks bro. defs gonna go amone > may thats locked in. i do like my cheapies but your right i have alot of NPR so ill keep on eye on koula. smith should make some money was unlucky not to get points last week. ive already used 2 trade boosts so im trying not to burn them all
Wait for teams and rethink it , Katoa bench probably, Tui and McD may not get a run Vailea fit (rumours) but likely misses
That is quite a hole you have dug there
$$itb
Sheldon(@sheldon)
Gun
1 year ago
#1069512
Marshall King – Grant
Amone – Koula
Smith/Valiea/Tuiliga – May
Got real lucky as I nearly went Amone to Naden today.
Parker was out with covid so will koula keep his spot or revert to 14 if Walker is out ? Turbo could also be out so maybe there is a starting spot there. Thoughts ?
Not sure when the positive test was but with sea eagles playing Thursday he might be still in 7 day isolation period?
WoolyScore(@woolyscore)
Borderline keeper
1 year ago
#1069530
What a miserable SuperCoach weekend for me. My 2 trades were:
Moses -> Hynes
Randall -> Starling
That cost me 131 points through no fault but my own. But to put icing on the cake, I had Billy Smith, Amone and Sloan in my CTW which gave me Momoseia’s 16 and a big fat donut.
Koula & Schiller are the same price.
May is cheaper than Hastings.
Unless I’m missing something I can’t see an issue for you.
weebs(@weebs)
Gun
1 year ago
#1069549
First right C choice this year on Papz and then Moses going wild as well boosted me to 1445.
Really not keen to trade Fifita out since he hasn’t been scoring terrible compared to other 2RF. I guess it’s just his price that’s the downer.
Anyone flicking him for Ipap?
How much money is Momo going to lose…Id go Amone to May amd Staggs to a keeper…Im really tempted by Tupou.
White Line Fever(@backhander)
Rookie
1 year ago
#1069553
Just wondering is it possible to reverse my trade of D brown to Munster and change my captain back to papenhausen instead of Munster after having.a bad dream last night where paps scored 196, brown 131 and munster 33. Thanks in advance.
Nailed it…Thank God I traded him last week to May ( who I didn’t play 🙁 )
Sally M(@sally-m)
Gun
1 year ago
#1069565
Magic number has again increased marginally from 9420 to 9445 after starting the season at 8767. It typically decreases over the course of the season. With scoring starting to return to more typically higher scores I think the MN may have peaked this week and I would expect it to commence its usual decline from here for the season. To calculate a breakeven, use the following formula. Breakeven = ( ( Players current salary / Magic Number ) x 3 ) – last two scores e.g. Paphenhuyzen = ( ( 796100 / 9445 ) x 3 ) – 107 -193… Read more »
Bozzin8r(@bozzin8r)
Gun
1 year ago
#1069566
I went early on May last week to fund other upgrades, so thinking of holding trades this week. The only real issue in my team is Dfif underperforming, and Amone now having a -1 in his rolling average..
First trade out is Staggs. He has not produced the goods.
Will be hard not to boot Amone but there are so many that need to go!
I could blow my supercharges in the first six week alone. I have to restrict it to two. Thankfully I have 250k in the bank.
Every time I trade someone out they go ballistic. That said, I can’t afford to even leave him on the bench because it’s tempting fate.
If there’s any truth to the intimations of trouble in Red Hill, especially if that Haas video isn’t rubbish then the Broncos are toxic.
Trade out d fifita for me would ya
My pod katoa and bully to may and someone under $400k.
What position can it be ?
Trade outs
D Fifita
S Walker
Hiku
Mahoney
Momoisea
JTB
Which 3 go?
Fifita, Walker and Mahoney aren’t trade outs in my opinion.
Yep just leave 3
Beg to differ on Mahoney. He can’t crack 60 with a try. Even the 300-400k mid-range hookers are matching his base (less than 40 minus missed tackles).
The only plus he has right now is his forthcoming draw: Wests; Knights; Cowboys.
Unless there is something else going on that I do not see, Mahoney is not justifying his price.
Momoisea is about to become a starting second-rower, with frizell, fitzgibbon and barnett out.. Wouldnt be selling now.
hey gents having the worst year ever and i need advice on how i should fix my team. been a fall from grace compared to least year didnt even crack 900 this week. i do plan to bring in may and then upgrade katoa to either cotter or talakai
starling / randall
Haas / AFB / King / King
Fifita Ola Katoa / tuilagi macdonald piakura
cleary / schiender
munster / ilias
bsmith tago amone penisini / russell vailea burbo
hynes / teddy
Mate even with may it might just give u 3 ctrs. go b smith + amone to manly young gun plus may first. Then maybe a boost for katoa if on bench again but with jazz out Curran maybe back to 13 he might start
Don’t panic brother. A week to forget for anyone who didn’t Captain Papy. You have a really good team that may very well score 1300 next week. Cleary, Hynes and Munster won’t score 100 points combined very often.
thanks for the words gents boosted my spirit. all the best for the rest of the season
I think you need to bring in Cook or Grant for Starling
Trade Cleary out for the cash and bring him back once he proves he can reach 2021 scores again and he bottoms out in price
Get a dual 2RF/CTW like Aitkins or Fermour
Bring in Pappy
Cleary out Hynes to HB Pappy in
Amone out for May or Koula
piakura or underperforming CTW out for Fermor/Aitken
or starling out for Grant
My 2cents worth,
looks like you don’t have many players generating cash
thanks bro. defs gonna go amone > may thats locked in. i do like my cheapies but your right i have alot of NPR so ill keep on eye on koula. smith should make some money was unlucky not to get points last week. ive already used 2 trade boosts so im trying not to burn them all
Wait for teams and rethink it , Katoa bench probably, Tui and McD may not get a run Vailea fit (rumours) but likely misses
That is quite a hole you have dug there
$$itb
Marshall King – Grant
Amone – Koula
Smith/Valiea/Tuiliga – May
Got real lucky as I nearly went Amone to Naden today.
I have Smith and I’m inclined to hold since he should be back soon and the Roosters are starting to look better.
Was he dropped for form or injury? I heard it was form?
Haas and Kelly in trouble @ the broncos. Just to add to the fun
There’s a video apparently
A drunken push , they will get fined I think.
Looked like old footage and handbags at dawn would be an appropriate description. Not ideal but not much in it…
One of Twitter comments I noted:
“I blame Madge… he has really lost the broncos dressing room”…
Anyone selling Haas……?
Time to fix my CTW
Locked in:
Amone – May
Cobbo – Fermor
Maybe:
Vailea – Koula
Parker was out with covid so will koula keep his spot or revert to 14 if Walker is out ? Turbo could also be out so maybe there is a starting spot there. Thoughts ?
There was talk during the week that Lionel Ritchie was going to get dropped so maybe he got a stay of execution due to Parker’s covid dilemma.
Not sure when the positive test was but with sea eagles playing Thursday he might be still in 7 day isolation period?
What a miserable SuperCoach weekend for me. My 2 trades were:
Moses -> Hynes
Randall -> Starling
That cost me 131 points through no fault but my own. But to put icing on the cake, I had Billy Smith, Amone and Sloan in my CTW which gave me Momoseia’s 16 and a big fat donut.
Hope everyone did a lot better than me!!!
Blame Griffin, what an absolute spanner. There’s some bad coaches going around.
Rage trades will make you feel better!
Lol thanks Vertigo. All of a sudden Randall playing 80 as well, where did that come from
already bringing in May for Amone
but is it worth also bringing in Koula?
Last week, 489 people traded out Moses for Hynes and 279 traded him out for Munster.
OUCH!
Yep 1 was me… I am in total pain
sorry to hear that mate, it can happen to the best of us.
Just remember it is a marathon not a sprint
Fingers crossed im able to do May & Koula for Hastings & Schiller, only have 80k in the bank
Koula & Schiller are the same price.
May is cheaper than Hastings.
Unless I’m missing something I can’t see an issue for you.
First right C choice this year on Papz and then Moses going wild as well boosted me to 1445.
Really not keen to trade Fifita out since he hasn’t been scoring terrible compared to other 2RF. I guess it’s just his price that’s the downer.
Anyone flicking him for Ipap?
Yeah, I’ve always thought Fifi was like sex: when it’s good, it’s really good and when it’s bad it’s still pretty good.
Go check the Titans draw…Its a horrible run coming up…Not saying that will effect Fifita massively but it will hurt the Titans in general I believe.
Had a bad week…
Staggs & Cobbo need to go, but I’m going to try and get disciplined and drop Amone and Momosiea first… $230k itb, so May and someone else…
How much money is Momo going to lose…Id go Amone to May amd Staggs to a keeper…Im really tempted by Tupou.
Just wondering is it possible to reverse my trade of D brown to Munster and change my captain back to papenhausen instead of Munster after having.a bad dream last night where paps scored 196, brown 131 and munster 33. Thanks in advance.
Ooof
Who to sell for May
TU: Staggs
TD: Hiku
Games open so can an amone owner tell me what happened.
In terms of his score? He came on with 10 minutes to go (give or take) and didn’t do anything.
Nailed it…Thank God I traded him last week to May ( who I didn’t play 🙁 )
Magic number has again increased marginally from 9420 to 9445 after starting the season at 8767. It typically decreases over the course of the season. With scoring starting to return to more typically higher scores I think the MN may have peaked this week and I would expect it to commence its usual decline from here for the season. To calculate a breakeven, use the following formula. Breakeven = ( ( Players current salary / Magic Number ) x 3 ) – last two scores e.g. Paphenhuyzen = ( ( 796100 / 9445 ) x 3 ) – 107 -193… Read more »
I went early on May last week to fund other upgrades, so thinking of holding trades this week. The only real issue in my team is Dfif underperforming, and Amone now having a -1 in his rolling average..