nick1085

Site co-founder and all round SC tragic, Nick no longer writes too much these days but hosts the SC Report each week and looks after most of the site administration.

1631
Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
432 Comment threads
1199 Thread replies
11 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
270 Comment authors
RoyPanther4lyfArmandokasiano.royalerockafella Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
Notify of
thenoideas
Member
Gun
thenoideas

Smith cook
Taupau surgess James tolman
Jurbo martin arrow lolo tohu kikau
Sj Cleary
Widdop brimson
Marsters aitken issako Hopoate croker mann fusitua
Turbo teddy
4 trades left 280k itb

Any trade ideas? Probably going to hold, got my eye on some gun ctw like aj latrell fergo etc but I’m not in any real rush considering their be.

Due to low trades and a stacked frf/2rf I will probably hold on to tohu.

Ideally brimson to Munster/calker is my next move. Then pretty much done for the year barring any injuries

Just Do It
Member
Just Do It

Hey Guys thoughts on Croker to AJ and Isaako to WBlake or Hoppa. Or hold off on second trade as I got 9 left. Cheers

Souffs
Member
Gun
Souffs

9 is a lot. I’d do them.

jc001
Member
Gun
jc001

anyway u can keep isaako? i would hold him rather than bringing in blake, hoppa brings stability

Pablo Bill
Member
Gun
Pablo Bill

I’d keep Isaako, he’ll pump out a few more big games and kicks goals, depends on other CTW’s as well, will you have to play him every week? He’s my 5th CTE ATM based on matchups and home games coming up

Just Do It
Member
Just Do It

Thanks all for response and I think I’ll hold fire on isaako trade as he is my 5th CTW… I am running with AJ now, GuthoPod, Marsters, Aitken and Isaako as back up with 2 nuffs

TurkeySnow
Member
Gun
TurkeySnow

Also Isakoo came out and said he didn’t play good and needed to turn it around, didn’t have a score under 60 I think before that game.

Just Do It
Member
Just Do It

Wow i didn’t see that from him. But you all have convinced me to hold fire on Isaako and do the Croker to AJ only. Cheers

Pablo Bill
Member
Gun
Pablo Bill

Exact same CTW’s as me mate, plus Mann still ATM

rockafella
Member
Gun

wake blake is not a option at all

kc10
Member
Gun
kc10

Tough choice for last reserve:

Surgess, Kikau or Munster?

doug
Member
Gun
doug

Im playing surgess and kikau
Munster could score 10 or 90 this week so many variables for him at the moment, croft outside him, hows his finger gunna hold up, playing in new zealand.

TurkeySnow
Member
Gun
TurkeySnow

Yeah I feel Kikau and Surgess are safer options this week, Kikau I was thinking of sitting out but is a beast playing 80min, and likely running at Niko this week no way anyone should leave him out.

Dick Dastardly
Member
Gun
Dick Dastardly

Munster

Roy
Member
Keeper
Roy

As most have discussed, CTW is also an issue for me.

Currently have:

Matto
Mitchell
Isaako
Nene
Marsters
Katoa
Olive

I’d like to bring in one more but no sure who AND not sure who for. 6 trades left with 195K ITB

thinking Nene/Katoa > Hayne/Blake/Mansour/Rapa

???? Stuck

Boffa
Member
Gun
Boffa

katoa to go. who knows who to bring in.

jc001
Member
Gun
jc001

ha so true!

i’m looking at hayne and mansour, but i would do mansour next week

Pablo Bill
Member
Gun
Pablo Bill

AJ? Love a fullback in the CTW’s, best attacking team in the comp and should back another 5+ tries to close out season

mresky
Member
mresky

if you make the finals do you get extra trades?

Howard Moon
Member
Gun
Howard Moon

no mate

Dick Dastardly
Member
Gun
Dick Dastardly

No.

Howard Moon
Member
Gun
Howard Moon

Hi guys,

Current plan is to run with 1xHOK, 2x2RF & 1xFB as my reserves but want cover in FRF, halves and CTW.
9 trades remaining and $290k ITB

Any thoughts on the following trades this week:
– TPJ out for Surgess leaving Kikau as my FRF cover
– Croker out for Fergo leaving Matteron as my CTW cover until he gets his minutes back up

Cook, Smith

Taupau, Kikau, TPJ, FRF Nuff

Lolo, Arrow, Jurbo, Martin, Crichton, FRF/2RF Nuff

SJ, Brimson

Munster, 6/7 Nuff

Marsters, AJ, Aitken, Matterson, Croker, 2RF/CTW Nuff, 2RF/CTW Nuff

Teddy, Turbo

TurkeySnow
Member
Gun
TurkeySnow

like the trades, surgess getting 80 is gold and was close to a try/looks hungry for one last week.

I was set to sell James for Jurbo but am going TPJ to hold James, 3rd highest scoring frf. And hammy may not hold up.Just watch with Fergo a lot of talk about a groin injury

zen
Member
Gun
zen

Any stats about with Croker out of Raiders?

Is Gutho to Hayne to sideways.

Looking for a ctw with Mitchell,Aitken & Gutherson.

Souffs
Member
Gun
Souffs

From memory he missed the first couple rounds last year so just go into supercoach stats and look there if I’m correct.

TurkeySnow
Member
Gun
TurkeySnow

Last reserve

Agree it could be one of those two,

1. Three reserves from:
SJ – under 60 against storm in 2017/2016
Watson – had 79 on titans this year
Smith – 69 (this year before announcing SOO retirenent), 94, 87 (2017), 57 (2016)
Papalli – 89 this year, 66, 64 (2017), 42 (2016)
James – 36 This year, 83, 61 (2017), 41 (2016)
Oates – 27 (2017),14 (2016)

2. Pick 1 of:
Teddy – 48 this year and 137, 47 (2017), 157 (2016) at the tigers.
Turbo – 37 this year, 134, 68 (2017), 45 (2016)

Or

3. play both Teddy and Turbo and 2 from the top list?

jc001
Member
Gun
jc001

wow

watson, teddy, papa, hard to leave out sj

TurkeySnow
Member
Gun
TurkeySnow

have James and Papa against sharks and knights tbh, may be between teddy and Smith for final R I am thinking. Watson could score well and SJ but his AV against storm havent been great.

rockafella
Member
Gun

raiders might get a touch up this week.
They are missing crocker, tapine sezer and the fullback ..(forgot his name)
That is a good number out against a top 4 team..
i would leave papa out .
James or watson .

kegs kings
Member
Gun
kegs kings

Wash your mouth out mate lol.

doug
Member
Gun
doug

Thumbs up :Do we need another forum/ write up on who the best match ups are heading into the finals, seeing as though everyone has 20+ guns and dont know who to play??
Thumbs down : stupid idea, everyone needs to make their own decisions as thats super coach and all part of the fun.

Pablo Bill
Member
Gun
Pablo Bill

Don’t know about a new forum, I don’t mind having trade and team review in same forum as mainly use phone app so easier to navigate rather that flick back and forth.

jc001
Member
Gun
jc001

who would you hold? James or Tohu?

TU James
TD Tohu

jnrglover
Member
Gun
jnrglover

Hold both for the run home.

jc001
Member
Gun
jc001

would like to bring in jurbo and either papa or crichton…

Pablo Bill
Member
Gun
Pablo Bill

Crichton then Jurbo over big poppa pap

FBK
Member
Gun
FBK

Depending on trades: Overall hold James, H2H hold Tohu

TurkeySnow
Member
Gun
TurkeySnow

Honestly I feel Jurbo or Papalli both outscore Tohu, both close to getting 80min in the middle. James in FRF has 3rd highest av and similar plays 80 min, with arrow back futakai/wallace move back to froward rotation so hopefully he doesnt get pushed to an edge again. Backing him for a big score against knights, look what vave did close to the line, truned around and went over and he is no where near james for frf.

Sonnysideup
Member
Gun
Sonnysideup

I can’t say how badly I want James to move back to an edge twisted

BT
Member
Gun
BT

Hold the uninjured one.