Getting cold feet on my Hynes to S Johnson planned trade. Is it a worthwhile trade over Origin and then target Hynes later on to replace him via Peachey and B Smith downgrades, etc?
If I was to trade Hynes, would I be better served grabbing Walker via I Katoa and then possibly I Katoa to SJ next round?
Think it depends what the cash allows you to do + numbers, but don’t think Hynes > SJ is worth it. Hynes > Calker might be then re-evaluate Katoa next week
Means one less number this round but Haas kept instead of Katoa. Likely forces Ponga, etc to replace Murray via dual position players in the coming rounds or Walker next round if both Haas and Murray are traded next round via dual position players.
Last edited 4 months ago by Connoisseur
Michael(@duke-silver)
Borderline keeper
4 months ago
#1109560
Contemplating reversing my last trade
TU: AJ
TD: Isaako (using a boost going Williame > Jed Cartwright for extra $)
have 13 with only 2 trades used, pretty strong apart from keppie and Katoa. Rocketed into top 3000’s last few weeks overall but my h2h comp is a punish and I could really use the win, I sit in 7th of 12 despite being 2nd highest ranked overall(he has me by about 15 points)
22 trades left
TU: bring in tapine for haas (reduced minutes over origin)
& ponga for turbo
TD: hold tight
Comment: one of the two trades but not the other
Isaako… in retrospect!!
Banner already knows its a failure this season
weebs(@weebs)
Gun
4 months ago
#1109575
Damn should have traded BMM instead of couchman
Shanky(@ianlamb79)
Gun
4 months ago
#1109576
Ah the joys of supercoach. Hynes to Calker via Katoa, accidentally left c on Hynes’ Spot from last week to get Katoa’s score completely blowing any chance of even a vc play. Sitting too 3000’s overall and it’s not the first time I’ve stuffed up like this either. Probably lose another easy h2h that I should’ve won off the back of this… ive still got 3 trades so I’ll probably have to burn them now because I’m hellbent on wining my h2h this week!
Does anyone know if my accidental C Katoa is my lowest score and I have more than 13 does he drop out and I get my vc score? It’s a Hail Mary but I’m hoping!
I just checked rules, it says if his doubled score as captain is my lowest it drops out, hopefully it stays low(currently on 23, 46 doubled for c) I can see at least one of my players scoring lower than 46 either way so my best hope is some junk time points unfortunately…
He’ll drop out if it’s the lowest score, but VC doesn’t double. It’s the same as if your captain gets injured or HIA early in a game, you just have to wear it.
i have vc on isaako.so if i take c off hopgood and put c on a bye player in my 13 starters ,does that mean i get isaako doubled to keep plus the best 12 other scores in my 17 nominated players,can someone enlighten an older participant please?
If you have more than 13 players do you get the normal ae for your loop meaning you get your 11 best and 1 worst score. Can’t figure that one out and I have the dreaded te whare 4 staring at me
Not unless you have more than 16 players this week. An AE is your lowest scoring non selected player. So as long as all your players are selected then you don’t get an AE but will get your 13 best scores from your selected players. You won’t have a non selected player from a loop until you have 17 players and drop one out to loop.
Hope this makes sense 🙂
Honestly both could tonne up but won’t Moses be running at a Cows left side of Lucy, Laybutt and Derby? If so Moses will be calling for it all night.
I have Brown but will be looping Isaako just in case it’s one of those games where Dylbags catches a cold because of Moses.
think Moses has a ton of upside against that Cowboys right side, and it helps that he’s kicking goals too. having said that, DBags is probably more consistent, but i went with Moses so i could also put the C on Cody
You have to VC one of them, don’t put the C on them. It is a free chance to loop. Just put your C on a player on the bye, and if Moses or Brown flop, you can always go someone from that later games
I wanted to do that too but If I VC one of them it leaves me with C choices of Marzhew, Garrick or Harris. Which I’m not too fond of leaving it down to that. Harris probably safest pick (as long as can keep knee together). Should’ve VCd Isaako but didn’t think. Don’t have Cody.
You don’t have to C those guys if either of them go well, just put the C on a bye player and get the VC as your captain.
It is a free throw at the stumps.
Any of those will be a great option if Moses/Brown cop a head knock early in the game.
If those 2 fail, there is going to be a lot of people in the same boat as you. I assume Brown would be up there as highest VC option this week
Rabs85(@rabs85)
Keeper
4 months ago
#1109623
The Banner is H2H focussed
The Duke(@the-duke)
Gun
4 months ago
#1109629
Now if Kodi Nikorima can do me a solid and get 28k added to his price from that piddling score then he will be traded out, Pongo moved up, and Tommy Turbo gets re-recruited into my side next week.
Getting cold feet on my Hynes to S Johnson planned trade. Is it a worthwhile trade over Origin and then target Hynes later on to replace him via Peachey and B Smith downgrades, etc?
If I was to trade Hynes, would I be better served grabbing Walker via I Katoa and then possibly I Katoa to SJ next round?
Think it depends what the cash allows you to do + numbers, but don’t think Hynes > SJ is worth it. Hynes > Calker might be then re-evaluate Katoa next week
Means one less number this round but Haas kept instead of Katoa. Likely forces Ponga, etc to replace Murray via dual position players in the coming rounds or Walker next round if both Haas and Murray are traded next round via dual position players.
Contemplating reversing my last trade
TU: AJ
TD: Isaako (using a boost going Williame > Jed Cartwright for extra $)
I still can’t decide between AJ & Isaako either lol
If I had the money I would go Isaako, but I’m $30k short without boosting
Williame to Cartwright is yuck
TU- I Fa’asuamaleaui > S Fainu
TD – Dunster > Te Whare
Comment that I’m wasting trades but trying to get an extra player and hoping they make some cash eventually
Comment
commentaire
have 13 with only 2 trades used, pretty strong apart from keppie and Katoa. Rocketed into top 3000’s last few weeks overall but my h2h comp is a punish and I could really use the win, I sit in 7th of 12 despite being 2nd highest ranked overall(he has me by about 15 points)
22 trades left
TU: bring in tapine for haas (reduced minutes over origin)
& ponga for turbo
TD: hold tight
Comment: one of the two trades but not the other
Only worth it if you have a dud score you want to drop out of your 13
Banner predictions?
Calker, Brown, Ponga although with the vanilla banner letdowns this year maybe a Tohu or Tapine
Cook
Josh Schuster
Jake Granville
Isaako… in retrospect!!
Banner already knows its a failure this season
Damn should have traded BMM instead of couchman
Ah the joys of supercoach. Hynes to Calker via Katoa, accidentally left c on Hynes’ Spot from last week to get Katoa’s score completely blowing any chance of even a vc play. Sitting too 3000’s overall and it’s not the first time I’ve stuffed up like this either. Probably lose another easy h2h that I should’ve won off the back of this… ive still got 3 trades so I’ll probably have to burn them now because I’m hellbent on wining my h2h this week!
Does anyone know if my accidental C Katoa is my lowest score and I have more than 13 does he drop out and I get my vc score? It’s a Hail Mary but I’m hoping!
Has to be on a non starter. So if he was to drop out of your 13 you would have no captain score at all (your VC won’t count)
I just checked rules, it says if his doubled score as captain is my lowest it drops out, hopefully it stays low(currently on 23, 46 doubled for c) I can see at least one of my players scoring lower than 46 either way so my best hope is some junk time points unfortunately…
He’ll drop out if it’s the lowest score, but VC doesn’t double. It’s the same as if your captain gets injured or HIA early in a game, you just have to wear it.
TU: AJ
TD: Ponga
looking like an isaako loop!
I’ve put the the vc on him . How do we loop it
I just C’d a bye player in my 17 and double points are already loaded
Cheers . Don’t know if I should keep the C on Dylan brown
Hard choice. But what if brown goes down injured. Isaako points are the safe play I guess. Guaranteed.
vtw comes on with 3mins left to ruin cash gen lol damn
Happy with new recruits JMK an Isaako. Will be looping Isaako.
With 15 playing I’m quietly hoping for a few low scores from the more highly owned players. Schuster, I’m looking at you
My exact recruits. Plus Tohu . Very happy x want to loop isaako
Yeah I got Tohu and Cody as well
i have vc on isaako.so if i take c off hopgood and put c on a bye player in my 13 starters ,does that mean i get isaako doubled to keep plus the best 12 other scores in my 17 nominated players,can someone enlighten an older participant please?
If you have more than 13 players do you get the normal ae for your loop meaning you get your 11 best and 1 worst score. Can’t figure that one out and I have the dreaded te whare 4 staring at me
Not unless you have more than 16 players this week. An AE is your lowest scoring non selected player. So as long as all your players are selected then you don’t get an AE but will get your 13 best scores from your selected players. You won’t have a non selected player from a loop until you have 17 players and drop one out to loop.
Hope this makes sense 🙂
Thanks heaps mate appreciate it
Yes you do.
Toby Couchman. That’s my boy. I bought you purely for the bye rounds and you are delivering. You beauty.
Couchman is not a bad player at all. Needs more time on the field. Fellow Coachman supporter
Very promising player. Needs to start in front of some of his more high profile team mates.
Have had him since round 3 . Came in handy haha
yep, should have brought in Issako.
I would never have brought in Isaako if not for bye numbers. Man, i have been missing out. He can play and score good SC points eh
If you had both DBrown and Moses. Who would you Captain this round? I don’t have any other real choices and therefore can’t VC either
I think Moses, purely because he has a higher ceiling from what ive seen and the upside is worth a punt.
In hindsight, maybe Browns floor and current form is worth a safer play.
Yeah my thought with Brown was that he was the safer bet, still with the ability to get a good captains score
Brown
Honestly both could tonne up but won’t Moses be running at a Cows left side of Lucy, Laybutt and Derby? If so Moses will be calling for it all night.
I have Brown but will be looping Isaako just in case it’s one of those games where Dylbags catches a cold because of Moses.
Dyl plays on the left, so yep Moses at that right edge.
Struggling with this call myself. Have Isaako as VC but wondering whether to leave the C on Brown or not. Or even Cody Walker
I’d take Isaakos 109 prior to updates on a week like this
i’ve gone VC Moses, C Cody
think Moses has a ton of upside against that Cowboys right side, and it helps that he’s kicking goals too. having said that, DBags is probably more consistent, but i went with Moses so i could also put the C on Cody
Ditto
You have to VC one of them, don’t put the C on them. It is a free chance to loop. Just put your C on a player on the bye, and if Moses or Brown flop, you can always go someone from that later games
I wanted to do that too but If I VC one of them it leaves me with C choices of Marzhew, Garrick or Harris. Which I’m not too fond of leaving it down to that. Harris probably safest pick (as long as can keep knee together). Should’ve VCd Isaako but didn’t think. Don’t have Cody.
You don’t have to C those guys if either of them go well, just put the C on a bye player and get the VC as your captain.
It is a free throw at the stumps.
Any of those will be a great option if Moses/Brown cop a head knock early in the game.
Yeah meant to say if I VC one and they score sub par I’m restricted to those remaining players. Will C one of Moses or Brown. Just a tricky one..
If those 2 fail, there is going to be a lot of people in the same boat as you. I assume Brown would be up there as highest VC option this week
The Banner is H2H focussed
Now if Kodi Nikorima can do me a solid and get 28k added to his price from that piddling score then he will be traded out, Pongo moved up, and Tommy Turbo gets re-recruited into my side next week.
If his score stays at 36 he will increase by around $49K so pray for no downdates
Excellent. That will be my final unforced trade.
Dont forget mate that Turbo is on a bye next week
Kodi likely to go back to bench, unless Katoa gets a rest he coul go back to scoring 10 and lose all his cash
Turbo is on the bye next week
Oh,,,Buddha.