Wenin is one of the founding fathers of the NRLSCTalk website who's Tuesday Teams Analysis has been a feature post on the site for close to a decade. He also loves a good steak bet!
Thoughts on Arrow to Jamil and Walters to Cleary? With the Grant deal I might not be sacrificing too much cash generation and Cleary is a 5-10 point upgrade over Arrow.
I don’t understand the loop negativity, with a 20 AE you’re guaranteed 220 from theoretically 3 players, thats a 73avg. When we are generally just taking out a lowly CTW like Williame etc anyway
Youre in the same boat as majority of supercoaches and the same has been asked since last night and all day continuously. If you are happy with it take it.
Im another one pondering this decision. Last week i played JWill and was gonna play the same 17 this week but now starting to have 2nd thoughts. I think im kinda leaning toward Luai (but with no confidence)
Asked a few pages back but no-one knew/gave an answer. What injury did Tetevano have and why/how can he be playing within a week? Need to know whether keep or trade out. He’s only 300k so wouldn’t mind keeping.
Thoughts on Arrow to Jamil and Walters to Cleary? With the Grant deal I might not be sacrificing too much cash generation and Cleary is a 5-10 point upgrade over Arrow.
I like the trade
Sounds like you’ve convinced yourself. Go for it
Already have Katoa?
Yeah and JTB and Rudolf.
How long is Hoppa3 expected to last?
Popular teams for starters and cashies playing tonight
Whats your mix
5 starters and 2 cows for me
4 / 1 plus whichever category people view Carrigan in
if he is in your 17 he is a starter
Then it’s 5/1 for me!
7 and 3 for me!
8/3
8 starters and 3 cheapies.
Is JWilliams to E. Katoa worth doing early? Got a feeling I will be wanting to use 2 trades on my CTW next week.
I always hold, what if he gets injured this week
Anyone could get injured. I’d do it
Poetic
Good trade in my view as I’ll definitely be using 2 trades next week
thoughts on Arrow > Horse this week, which then allows me to go Simo, Lomax > Marsters, Yeo next week?
not 100% on Horse but am concerned with Arrow’s potentially low minutes with their bench, plus gets me two CTW guns (or at least i hope so) next week
I’m tossing up something very similar, haven’t used any trades yet. Going from Arrow to Horse does open up $200K for upgrades next week.
Could turn Lomax & Waqa in to Marsters & Yeo/Isaako. (Only if Lomax & Waqa bomb this week)
Ryan Sutton still hanging around on the extended bench, may eat into Horse’s minutes.
I went for Katoa this week to get a better gauge on Horse’s minutes.
What’s the reasoning behind the Round chat not opening up before the Round starts?? Is it tradition
Gives them time to decide who gets the banner. 😉
Always been that way.
Increases the suspense of the banner curse!
I can’t handle a banner curse right now
Then who am I to argue
Wauchope lad ?
Haha good memory bud.. nah just like his name
With Hodgo under an injury cloud…would you play him (TU) or E Katoa instead (TD)??
Cheers
Plenty of garbage on social media, but good to see people buying Warriors’ memberships going viral (as a thank you for them sticking around).
Any updates on whether Isaako is out? Ideally would like to know before Dragons match.
All mail has been broncos lining up 1-17. surely if isaako has to leave he will play tonight and fly out after.
Simo owners. What are we doing?
TU: Trading, may need both trades next week.
TD: Hold fire.
He’s not going to get much ball out there. Might bag a lucky try or two, but I see him as a Lomax that doesn’t kick goals.
Trade out for me.
Not this week …
He bags a double against a warriors side which will fire for 10 and get beat by 50 in 70 …
2 try simmo this week ..
Owner
Gurus,
Keep the C on Moses and hope he cracks the tonne or loop LoLos 100 and bank 200points???
Whats your AE and who would he come in for?
100 is not a loopable score unless in a bye round
I don’t understand the loop negativity, with a 20 AE you’re guaranteed 220 from theoretically 3 players, thats a 73avg. When we are generally just taking out a lowly CTW like Williame etc anyway
Because 100 points isn’t worth a loop, especially with a 20 AE. A sure-fire way to leave you in a hole.
Why isn’t 220 worth it when at this time of the year we’re mainly playing bad CTW’s!?
It’s not 220 though. You’ll be removing one of your 17 in order to sub in the NPR. What would that player have scored?
Do the maths here and work out if it’s worth it.
https://www.nrlsupercoachstats.com/vcloop.php
It is 220 Lolo & Avarillo, may end up 240
Youre in the same boat as majority of supercoaches and the same has been asked since last night and all day continuously. If you are happy with it take it.
Katoa or Luai last reserve. Dont mind Katoa starting, Carty scored 50 there last week including -7 in missed tackles.
Katoa
I went Luai personally, running at that Dragon’s edge is too tasty.
Why not both
Better options than them mate.
If you have both Luai and Katoa in your 17, you should start questioning the makeup of your squad.
I benched Hess for Katoa this week, really need a big performance from him…
I played Hess, had him for a try, cows 1-12 and under 40 points….. was really not happy about that junktime try when Val holmes was being lazy.
Hess had single digits in H8 though, i geuss lolo took all the runs.
Just a bit worrying that a backrower with a try+lb only scored 70, seems to back up my thought from last week his base is only 35-40
Will update to 80 and im really liking the cows halves this year. should see him and cooper score a few trys. That double movement was so frustrating.
walters easily
Is Turbo to Ponga (papy res) this week, to allow arrow>lolo next week ok?
Has to be another way. Turbo could go HUGE next week (and any week).
No, trading a proven GUN after week 1 is not ok. Find another way
Sideways. Turbo is a proven gun and playing Warriors next week. Stay strong and definitely definitely hold. No doubt
Solid no from the boys…thanks lads
Dude……last 4 season averages : 77,74,76,65.
As Billy said, find another way.
J Williams, Walters or Luai last reserve?
Same decision – gone for Walters.
Im another one pondering this decision. Last week i played JWill and was gonna play the same 17 this week but now starting to have 2nd thoughts. I think im kinda leaning toward Luai (but with no confidence)
Just made that very same change.
With williams playing the storm Walters is probably the safest option.
Round 2 chat is up
Asked a few pages back but no-one knew/gave an answer. What injury did Tetevano have and why/how can he be playing within a week? Need to know whether keep or trade out. He’s only 300k so wouldn’t mind keeping.
its in the rd2 chat page minor knee injury 4th min. could have been precautionary
** repost** didnt get a reply before lockout & feel like im missing something
rd1 1074 & 5.5k bank
cs9 (bb)
C haas knight (musgrove rudolf)
lolo fifi carrigan arrow hess sua
moses (walters)
sj (luai)
shiby lomax watkins hampton (kennedy williame fui)
VC holmes ponga
i want gwill & koro but can see how i can sell anyone
4/320! What a shame this can’t last!